A False System Of Education - Mary Wollstonecraft

74

By mrpopo

Mary Wollstonecraft was born in 1759 in England, the oldest daughter of an abusive farmer. Her work, A Vindication of the Rights of Woman, was released in 1792, and is now recognized as a landmark treatise on women's rights. Its notion that culture rather than nature is the determiner of much gender difference foreshadows later feminist theory, and some aspects of environmental psychology as well.


Wollstonecraft's revolutionary work in Vindication contained a passage, "A False System of Education". In the following article, I will be discussing some of her points and elaborating on them to find a meaning more apt to modern society.

A False System of Education

Equality is an essential aspect in our lives. In many cultures, the idea of respecting individuals of all races, genders and religions has been steadily increasing over time.


In modern times it is almost a thing of the past to discriminate based on such characteristics. However, there are still problems with equality in our world, and overall there are many things which need to be addressed before it can be said that everyone is equal.


Firstly, we must define exactly what equality means. Instinctively we assume that it means that we are all equal, but the fact is that we are not all equal. Some of us are smarter than others; some are stronger and better skilled; some are more creative. The more accurate way of defining equality is through balance. Equality is balance in unequal things.


Socrates has taught us the importance of balance all too well, and here too it is of vital importance. As an example, men are physically stronger than women, on average. How can we create a balance in this unequal distribution of strength?


A simple solution would be to allow men to do the physical tasks and labours, and allow women tasks more suitable to their strengths such as being affectionate mothers. This solution is reflected throughout history and even in modern times, the only difference being that in modern times women have just as much of a choice as men do in choosing their tasks.


Mary Wollstonecraft argues of a lack of balance that existed until recently in that women are generally considered inferior to men. The argument consisted that women can be just as intelligent as men, but because of their weaker educations they have become mentally weak and believe their tasks became solely to love. This idea of giving women and men equal education is now reflected in at the very least Western society, where anybody can get an education.


Since the problems with gender inequalities in education are essentially solved in our modern times thanks to such writers as Wollstonecraft, I will address the issue with education itself. The lack of balance now lies not in whether a sex is being excluded from the education, but in the method of the education itself.


The main problems in current education systems include:

  • dependency, in which you must wait for instructions and procedures instead of solving the problem on your own
  • ineffective procedures, in which naturally easy tasks like arithmetic and literature become incredibly difficult when taught in an ineffective way
  • judgements by certified officials, which creates a sense that self-evaluation – the staple of every philosophical system that ever existed – is not a factor in your education, only the judgements of others.

This is the true false system of education.


The focus now should switch not of equal teachings to all human beings, but to balanced teachings to all human beings.


The current issues with the educational systems of today are unlike the issues women faced in previous centuries, yet they are exactly the same.


Women were made mentally weak with inferior education; is it any surprise that the youth of today, boy or girl, rich or poor, are indifferent to everything but toys and violence, being materialistic, and cannot concentrate for very long, being addicted to distraction?


Self-sufficiency of women may have been accounted for in the past, but the problem now is with the self-sufficiency of youth.


References:

Wollstonecraft, Mary. "A False System of Education" from Vindication. Classics of Western Philosophy. 1:190-199.

Recommended Books

Vindication of the Rights of Woman
Amazon Price: $0.00
Maria, or the Wrongs of Woman
Amazon Price: $0.00
A Vindication of the Rights of Woman and A Vindication of the Rights of Men
Amazon Price: $6.23
List Price: $10.95

More Philosophical Ramblings

Comments

Aley Martin profile image

Aley Martin Level 2 Commenter 24 months ago

Are you a philosophy major? You seem drawn to this type of thinking...Love it!

Isn't is a shame that there is always someone deemed "inferior" to another? At Mary's age it was women, and now it is the poor,disenfranchized, and minorities. Again, I reiterate it is all about "power" and people wanting to lord it over another. So silly really.

Great Hub MR!

mrpopo profile image

mrpopo Hub Author 24 months ago

Good guess :) these articles were all based off readings from my first year philosophy course, but I'm in a sciences major. Ironically though, that was the course which I struggled with the most, yet it's inspired the majority of my Hubs (though I only have a few...).

Thanks for stopping by, Aley!

habee profile image

habee Level 7 Commenter 24 months ago

I always taught a little about her in my Brit lit class. Enjoyed the read!

lxxy profile image

lxxy 24 months ago

I completely agree--the educational system has come along way in being gender neutral, but still has yet to move beyond it's self in many ways since then.

There's waaaaay too much importance for some on knowing exact dates and names when such information is trivial at best, and easy to find out at worst.

With the birth of the information age a new paradigm in learning has yet to emerge, but I am hopeful. I believe we now must not look to teach kids "what to know," but rather "how to learn."

mrpopo profile image

mrpopo Hub Author 24 months ago

@ habee - glad to see a teacher liked it! Thanks for stopping by :)

@ Ixxy - that is very true. Your last sentence says it all. I hope we come to realize that soon. Thanks for the comment :)

The Bard profile image

The Bard 22 months ago

Very informative and thought provoking. A hub right up my street.

tonymac04 profile image

tonymac04 22 months ago

The dependency issue is very important. We have to realise that education systems are generally run by governments and so are designed to instill in learners the kind of values that will enable government to function well, not to encourage learners to be independent thinkers. Governments don't as a rule like independent thinkers too much!

And the way learners are taught in an authoritarian mode encourages passivity and deppendence too.

Thanks for an interesting read.

Love and peace

Tony

mrpopo profile image

mrpopo Hub Author 22 months ago

@ The Bard - I'm glad you enjoyed the Hub! Thought provoking and a bit unsettling to ponder on, but that's the reality of the situation.

@ Tony - that's very true. I guess governments and independent thinkers are not very much compatible. Good point about the authoritarian mode. As a student myself I try to avoid the dependency created by these systems but it's quite hard not to, especially when at times the school simply spoon feeds the students. Even worse, other times the schools will teach at a standard higher than the capabilities of the student, and no learning can be accomplished.

I firmly believe you can maximize the potential of anybody but it must be done according to the individual's current capabilities and motivations. Having weak goals or impossible ones is not efficient for both tutor and learner. Not doing so results on students not able to think for themselves (I notice that more and more acutely with some of my friends, other students of this generation and even myself (Google is a two-edged sword)). It's unfortunate and doesn't really help with the evolution of teaching and learning. Thanks for stopping by!

wingedcentaur profile image

wingedcentaur Level 5 Commenter 22 months ago

Good Day mrpopo

I voted this up for useful. Thanks for an efficient, well-laid out presentation on a false system of education. The idea that "Equality is balance in unequal things," is one I wil be pondering.

Well done!

mrpopo profile image

mrpopo Hub Author 22 months ago

Good day wingedcentaur! I am glad you enjoyed the Hub.

The idea was one that took me by surprise when I first thought upon it. Usually we tend to consider equality as "equal treatment" or "equal opportunity" and it is - partially. But I then realized that we cannot have equal opportunity unless we are all exactly the same. Despite this, by providing balance we can still maintain a sense of equal opportunity.

It's funny, I wrote this in March or April but the thought of "equality is balance in unequal things" is still very new to me. It's an interesting way of looking at it, that's for sure!

Thanks for the comment!

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working